Estimating Fundamentals for ICI Subcontractors#

Executive Summary#

Estimating is the process of determining the expected cost to complete a project, then adding appropriate markup to establish a bid price. For ICI subcontractors, accurate estimating is essential for profitability—underestimate and lose money, overestimate and lose the bid. This guide covers the fundamentals of estimating including quantity takeoff, labor productivity factors, material pricing, and markup strategies.

The Context for ICI Subcontractors#

Unlike manufacturers who price standardized products, subcontractors price each project individually. Every project has different quantities, conditions, and requirements. The estimate translates project scope into expected costs, which become the basis for pricing.

Estimating skill directly affects business performance. Accurate estimators win profitable work. Inaccurate estimators either lose money on underpriced projects or fail to win work due to overpricing.

The Estimating Process#

Bid Document Review#

Estimating begins with thorough review of bid documents:

Drawings: Plans, sections, and details showing what is to be constructed

Specifications: Written requirements for materials, methods, and quality

General and special conditions: Contract terms affecting cost (schedule, liquidated damages, bonding requirements)

Addenda: Modifications to original bid documents

Complete review ensures nothing is missed. Missed scope items become unbillable cost.

Quantity Takeoff#

Quantity takeoff measures the amount of work required from the bid documents:

Linear measurements: Feet or meters of pipe, duct, or conduit to be insulated

Area measurements: Square feet or meters of surface to be covered

Counts: Number of fittings, valves, dampers, or other items

Systems: Major equipment or systems requiring work

Takeoff requires careful attention to detail. Every item shown in the documents must be counted and measured. Organization helps—systematic approaches (by floor, by system, by area) reduce the risk of missing items or counting twice.

Pricing Components#

With quantities determined, the estimate applies costs:

Labor: Hours required × labor rate
Materials: Quantities × unit prices
Equipment: Equipment needed × rental or usage rates
Subcontractors: Quotes from any work subcontracted
Other direct costs: Travel, permits, temporary facilities

Each component requires judgment and data to price accurately.

Labor Estimating#

Productivity Factors#

Labor estimating converts quantities to hours using productivity factors:

What productivity factors represent: How many units of work can be completed per labor hour

Example: An insulator might install 50 linear feet of 1" pipe insulation per hour in optimal conditions

Production rates vary based on:

Material type and thickness
Working conditions (accessibility, temperature, height)
Worker skill level
Project complexity

Sources of Productivity Data#

Historical data: Actual productivity from completed projects is the most reliable source. Job costing data showing hours required for specific work informs future estimates.

Published data: Industry publications provide standard productivity factors. These are useful starting points but may not reflect a specific contractor's actual performance.

Experience and judgment: Experienced estimators develop intuition about what their crews can accomplish.

Adjusting for Conditions#

Standard productivity factors must be adjusted for project conditions:

Access and space: Tight spaces, long travel distances, and difficult access reduce productivity

Height: Working at heights takes longer than working at floor level

Temperature: Extreme heat or cold reduces productivity

Schedule: Overtime and shift work have different productivity than standard hours

Complexity: Unusual configurations or requirements take longer

Labor Rate Calculation#

The labor rate used in estimates should reflect true cost:

Base wage: Hourly wage rate (which varies by classification)

Burden: Employer taxes, workers' compensation, benefits

Union contributions: If applicable, health and welfare, pension, training

Overhead allocation: Portion of overhead costs allocated per labor hour

A journeyperson with a $45 base wage might have a fully-burdened rate of $70 or more when all costs are included.

Material Estimating#

Quantity Calculation#

Material quantities derive from takeoff but must account for:

Waste: Material lost to cutting, fitting, damage, or spoilage

Standard sizes: Materials come in standard sizes that may not match project needs exactly

Accessories: Jacketing, adhesives, bands, and other materials beyond the primary insulation

Pricing Sources#

Material prices come from:

Supplier quotes: Prices quoted for the specific project

Pricing databases: Published prices or internal databases

Historical prices: Recent prices paid for similar materials

Material prices fluctuate. Estimates for projects bid far in advance may need price escalation factors.

Material Cost Elements#

Complete material cost includes:

Unit price: The price per unit of material

Tax: Sales tax where applicable

Freight: Delivery costs

Handling: Costs to receive and store materials

Equipment and Other Direct Costs#

Equipment#

Equipment costs include:

Owned equipment: Charge rates reflecting depreciation, maintenance, and operating costs

Rented equipment: Rental rates plus delivery, pickup, and fuel

Scaffolding: Erection, rental, and dismantling costs

Travel and Subsistence#

For projects requiring travel:

Travel pay: Per union agreement or company policy

Per diem: Meals and lodging for overnight work

Vehicle costs: Mileage or vehicle allowances

Permits and Fees#

Project-specific costs:

Permits: Required construction permits

Inspections: Testing and inspection fees

Licensing: Jurisdiction-specific licensing requirements

Indirect Costs and Overhead#

Project Indirect Costs#

Costs tied to a project but not to specific work items:

Project management: PM time allocated to the project

Supervision: Foreperson time for coordination, paperwork, meetings

Site facilities: Temporary offices, storage, utilities

Safety: Project-specific safety requirements beyond standard practices

Overhead Allocation#

General overhead must be recovered across projects:

Office overhead: Rent, utilities, insurance, administrative staff

Equipment overhead: Maintenance and storage of equipment fleet

General and administrative: Accounting, legal, executive costs

Overhead is typically allocated as a percentage of direct costs or labor costs.

Markup and Profit#

Markup Strategy#

Markup covers overhead recovery and profit. The appropriate markup depends on:

Competition: What markup will the market bear?

Risk: Higher-risk projects warrant higher markup

Desirability: Is this work the contractor wants to pursue?

Relationship: Existing relationships may justify different pricing

Capacity: When busy, higher markup; when slow, lower markup may be acceptable

Pricing to Win#

The goal is not just accurate estimating but winning profitable work. This requires understanding:

Market conditions: What are competitors likely to price?

Client expectations: What does this client value?

Competitive position: Does the contractor have advantages that justify premium pricing?

Bid Strategy Considerations#

Scope Clarifications#

Clarify scope ambiguities before bidding:

What does "complete" mean for each system?
What work is excluded?
What assumptions is the estimate based on?

Clear scope definition prevents disputes about what is included in the price.

Qualifications and Exclusions#

Document what is included and excluded:

Inclusions: Specifically what is covered by the bid

Exclusions: What is not included (work by others, overtime, work not shown, etc.)

Allowances: Items priced at allowance amounts subject to adjustment

Assumptions: Conditions assumed in preparing the estimate

Risk Assessment#

Identify and price risk:

Schedule risk: Penalties for delay, acceleration costs

Design risk: Incomplete or changing designs

Site risk: Unknown conditions, coordination problems

Payment risk: Customer creditworthiness

Higher-risk projects warrant higher markup or specific contingencies.

Estimating Accuracy#

Sources of Estimating Error#

Common causes of inaccurate estimates:

Incomplete takeoff: Missing quantities

Wrong productivity factors: Over- or underestimating labor efficiency

Price changes: Material prices different from estimate

Scope changes: Work required that was not apparent from bid documents

Condition differences: Site conditions different from expectations

Improving Accuracy#

Improve estimating accuracy through:

Job cost comparison: Compare estimates to actual costs on completed projects

Productivity tracking: Build database of actual productivity from field data

Feedback loops: Ensure estimators learn from project outcomes

Consistent methods: Standardize estimating approaches and checklists

Contingency#

Contingency addresses uncertainty:

Estimating contingency: Buffer for estimating accuracy

Design contingency: Buffer for incomplete design

Price contingency: Buffer for price escalation

The appropriate contingency level depends on estimate confidence, project complexity, and risk tolerance.

Organizing the Estimate#

Structure#

Well-organized estimates facilitate review and use:

Work breakdown: Organize by area, system, phase, or cost code

Labor and material separation: Show components separately

Summary levels: Roll up details to understandable summaries

Supporting documentation: Attach takeoff sheets, quotes, calculations

Documentation#

Maintain estimate documentation:

Takeoff sheets: What quantities were measured and how

Quotes: Supplier and subcontractor quotes used

Assumptions: What was assumed in preparing the estimate

Calculations: How numbers were derived

Documentation enables estimate review, revision, and comparison to actual costs.

How Appello Supports Estimating#

While Appello is primarily an operations platform, the Job Costing & Budgets module captures actual project costs that inform future estimating. By tracking labor hours, productivity, and costs at a detailed level, Appello provides the historical data that improves estimate accuracy over time.

When estimates become awarded jobs, budgets established from estimates provide the baseline for job cost comparison—closing the loop between what was estimated and what actually occurred.

Conclusion#

Estimating combines measurement, pricing, and judgment to determine what work will cost. The fundamentals—accurate takeoff, realistic productivity factors, current pricing, and appropriate markup—apply regardless of trade or project type.

Improving estimating accuracy requires ongoing attention: comparing estimates to actual costs, tracking productivity data, and learning from project outcomes. Contractors who invest in estimating capability win more profitable work and avoid the losses that come from inaccurate pricing.

Related Reading: